Unreleased Gems: Neil Young’s Chrome Dreams – Rust Edition

Neil Young Chrome Dreams Rust Edition cover

Good news: Neil Young has announced a Record Store Day exclusive: a limited vinyl box-set re-release of his “Ditch Trilogy” of albums, plus Zuma.

Sadly, however, there’s an album missing from that stellar line up.

Chrome Dreams might well be the best album Neil Young ever made, at a time (1976) when he was hitting a creative peak. Just look at the classic songs: Pocahontas, Like A Hurricane, Sedan Delivery, Powderfinger… It was so good, it even has a sequel, Chrome Dreams II.

What makes Chrome Dreams especially remarkable, of course, is that despite it being arguably Young’s finest achievement, it has never been officially released.

It’s an extraordinary thing. It’s the equivalent of AC/DC sitting on Back In Black…

By the mid seventies, Neil Young was hitting a peak of creativity. Having found the middle of the road with 1972’s “Harvest”, Young decided, in his own words, to “head for the ditch”. The three subsequent albums Young released over the next three years formed the “Ditch Trilogy”: an influential series of records that were a significant influence of the nineties grunge movement. “Time Fades Away” (1973), “On The Beach” (’74) and “Tonight’s The Night” (’75) confused many expecting a soft rock follow up to “Harvest”. “Zuma” followed these three (despite an album called “Ride My Llama” being touted at one point) and was well received. And still, by 1977 Young had two more albums ready to go – but released neither. “Homegrown” has still to be released and “Chrome Dreams” has surfaced in bootleg form only.

It’s an odd way to go about things – even “Tonight’s The Night”, was recorded before “On The Beach”, only to be temporarily shelved.

Embed from Getty Images

As Young himself wrote on Waging Heavy Peace, “Homegrown had been recorded and On The Beach had already been released when (guitarist) Ben Keith and I played the tapes at midnight in what is now known as the Belushi bungalow of Hollywood’s Chateau Marmont Hotel for Rick Danko of The Band and some other musicians. Rick said after hearing “Homegrown” and then “Tonight’s The Night”:  “You ought to put THAT out! What the hell is THAT?” So we did. It was Rick Danko who brought it back.”

Continues Young, “Homegrown, which I think is a great album, is still unreleased to this day. (It will come out, though, and we are preparing it now).”

However, as 1977 came around, Chrome Dreams was promised. It came as a surprise therefore that Young released instead the album “American Stars ‘n Bars”.

So what happened? It seems that Young decided not to release the album and instead drip feed various versions of the tracks onto other records.

Young said at the time about Chrome Dreams,  “Originally the concept was to have two sides on the album. One was going to be American history and the other was going to be social comment. The bar culture kind of thing where I was at the time, you know, drunk on my ass in bars. I couldn’t remember the history part so we left that out.”

Of the tracks, Pocahontas and Powderfinger had been earmarked for “Ride My Llama” but eventually turned up along with a turbo-charged version of Sedan Delivery on “Rust Never Sleeps”.

Hold Back The Tears appeared – with Linda Ronstadt on backing vocals – on American Stars ‘n Bars in a more countrified version than on Chrome Dreams.

So where can we find this “Unreleased” album? Well, there are a couple of options. I have created a Spotify playlist of many of the tracks that did appear on other albums, albeit in other forms. We could wait for Neil Young to finally release Chrome Dreams – it looks like Homegrown is on its way, so maybe Chrome Dreams will get the same treatment?

But if you can’t wait that long, for the real deal, there is YouTube and even a website or two that specialises in finding these unreleased bootleg albums (just Google Neil Young Chrome Dreams Rust Edition and you’ll find it). If you’re a Neil Young fan, and don’t have this in your collection, I think there Comes A Time when you have to put that right…

Sources: Neil Young: The Stories Behind The Songs by Nigel Williamson


17 responses to “Unreleased Gems: Neil Young’s Chrome Dreams – Rust Edition”

  1. mikeladano Avatar

    Neil Young may be the only artist who’s done a sequel album to an unreleased album.


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      You could be right *tries to think of another one* – nope, although doubtless someone will tell us if that’s not the case…


      1. mikeladano Avatar

        The only person I can think of with even a chance of this would be Prince, but I don’t think he’s done it either.


      2. Craig Avatar

        Beastie Boys Hot Sauce Committee Vol. 2.


      3. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

        A good effort – thank you!
        However, Wikipedia reckons that Pt 2 had the same track listing as pt 1, so maybe it doesn’t *quite* fit the bill…
        Good call though…


  2. monthofsundays94 Avatar

    This sounds eerily similar to the Beach Boys’ Smile album, which was released in altered form in 2011. And wasn’t on the beach not released on CD until the 2000s? What is with this neglecting of Neil’s work?


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      Yes that’s right. I believe it is Neil Young himself who decides not to release these albums. Quite why is a mystery, but Time Fades Away is still unavailable on CD, I believe.


      1. Craig Avatar

        It was pressed and given a catalog # when On The Beach, ASaB, Reactor et. al. (the so-called Missing 6) were finally released on cd in 2003.


  3. Tom Schabarum Avatar

    All these songs are on other albums, however, so all is not lost, I believe! That was my favorite Neil Young period up to and including RUST NEVER SLEEPS.


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      True, although the Chrome Dreams versions are different, and frequently better than the versions that eventually made it on album. And I’m with you on your favourite Neil Young period.


      1. Tom Schabarum Avatar

        I didn’t know that! Where do you find Chrome Dreams versions?


      2. Tom Schabarum Avatar

        Thanks! Can’t wait to hear one of my all time favorites in a different way: Will To Love… Amazing what is on that album and how it was all dispersed in different ways over so many other albums.


  4. J. Avatar

    One of his best for sure. I mind being given a bootleg version (on tape) years ago. Long since passed away, but I played that to death and can still hear the Chrome versions when I hear those songs.


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      Ah, the wonder of bootleg tapes!


  5. […] As I mentioned a little while back, Neil Young has more than one unreleased album dating back to the mid-seventies which is as good if not better than the ones that did get released. […]


  6. […] mentioned the story of Chrome Dreams some time ago (see this link) and the Acetate also has an interesting […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: