Buying Beatles, Dylan, Cash and Beach Boys on Vinyl

Album Collection with Johnny Cash and The beatles
The collection builds up….

Instead of buying the Oasis (What’s The Story) Morning Glory box set, I have decided to spend the same amount of money building as good a record collection as is humanly possible.

It isn’t clear quite why I am doing this. Probably some strange affectation, mid-life crisis or possible undiagnosed mental health issue. Best not to probe too deeply. Nevertheless, I am. So there. It’s going well.

With some decent records under my arm, I continued crate-digging around the Spitalfields record fair. Although the likes of Tapestry, Born To Run etc were literally in the bag, the collection felt a little lightweight. It was to time to bring in the big guns, and see which of the top ten albums in Rolling Stones’ 500 Greatest Albums I could snaffle within budget.

I started with the number one album,

Sgt Pepper The Beatles

The Beatles: Sgt Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band.


  • It’s the greatest.
  • Lovely gatefold sleeve, with lyrics printed on it, laminated, with insert (below) of Sergent Pepper’s moustache.

The Beatles Sgt Pepper Cut out


  • Could it have been an even better album? George Martin has said he regrets leaving out Penny Lane and Strawberry Fields Forever. The reason they were left off was because back then, the attitude was that singles and albums were kept separate…

I found a copy for £10 in decent condition. You can buy Sgt Pepper new for <£20 nowadays with the recent reissues, so there’s really no need to buy an original copy in poor condition.

Although my copy didn’t have the original inner sleeve, I had that covered. You may recall I found an old Chuck Berry album with an odd coloured sleeve way back in part 4?

The Beatles Lonely Hearts Club Band

Well, that was a distinctive and psychedelic sleeve designed by The Fool – a design collective from Holland – that was designed specifically for Sgt Pepper – and is only ever usually found in the earliest Sgt Pepper albums. A Chuck Berry album was an odd place to find it (it must have been swapped around at one point over the years), but a copy of Sgt Pepper with the original sleeve is more valuable than one without! I swapped the sleeves around and I now had a complete Sgt Pepper!

Next was….

The Beach Boys Pet Sounds

The Beach Boys: Pet Sounds.

Again, I found a decent copy for £10.


  • It’s #2 in Rolling Stones 500 Greatest Albums
  • It cost $70,000 to make (albeit that was nothing compared to the $50,000 it cost to make the “Good Vibrations” single).
  • Rolling Stone may rate it at number two now, but in November 1967 Jann Wenner criticised the Beach Boys after their non-appearance at Monterey (during which Jimi Hendrix stated “You heard the last of surfing music”) saying the “genius” label ascribed to Brian Wilson was a “promotional shuck” and that “The Beach Boys are just one prominent example of a group that has gotten hung up in trying to catch the Beatles”.


  • It’s another tenner out of the budget.
  • This was the first Beach Boys album on which none of the Beach Boys played instruments, and although it was a hit in the UK, it wasn’t promoted by Capitol in the USA, which focused instead on a Beach Boys best-of. Although it reached number 11 and sold half a million copies, this was fewer than the “Best of The Beach Boys” released eight weeks later and which reached number eight.
  • The main downside to this album was the effect that it had on the band (Mike Love hated Brian Wilson’s role as taskmaster “Who’s gonna hear this?” he asked. “The ears of a dog?”) and Brian Wilson’s health. The excellent “Heroes and Villains” book by Steven Gaines describes various examples of Wilson’s decline, including filling his den (where his piano sat) with sand and a tree house, and then moving on from extravagant home decoration to hashish, amphetamines and psychedelic drugs of various descriptions as he agonised over Pet Sounds’ successor, “Smile”..

Album Collection with Johnny Cash and The beatles

Bob Dylan: Highway 61 Revisited


  • #4 in the Top 500 albums.
  • Mine for a bargain £5.
  • Alongside the three “B” albums: “Bringing it all Back Home”, “Blonde on Blonde” and “Blood on the Tracks”, this is one of the core four “must have” Dylan albums.


  • The packaging is hardly lavish. But you don’t buy Dylan albums for the sleeve do you?
  • It was a later pressing, rather than a sixties original. That would have cost another £10…

The best bargain of the day however was this:

Johnny Cash at Folsom Prison

Johnny Cash: Live at Folsom Prison.

This classic live album was lurking in a half price bin for just £2.50.

CBS Label Johnny Cash Folsom Prison


  • It was a beauty, in laminated sleeve and an original UK CBS label copy.
  • The blood curdling cheers from the prison inmates at the line “I shot a man in Reno / just to watch him die”
  • On the reverse of the record cover is a thoughtful hand-written essay by Johnny Cash. Until I bought this album I was unaware of its existence (it wasn’t reprinted in my CD copy bought ten years ago). Cash writes “The culture of a thousand years is shattered with the clanging of the cell door behind you….I speak partly from experience – I have been behind bars a few times….Each time I felt the same feeling of kinship with my fellow-prisoners”. He speaks of envying a cockroach, as it can crawl out of the cell door…. It’s an extraordinary essay.

Johnny Cash Folsom Prison back cover


  • Yup, plenty of them. In the audience…

Next time I’ll wrap things up with what The Ultimate Record Collection ended up looking like. And then we’ll hopefully take a look at what happened when more bloggers had a go at deciding how to spend their money….the final part can be found via this link….





11 responses to “Buying Beatles, Dylan, Cash and Beach Boys on Vinyl”

  1. Tangled Up In Music (by Ovidiu Boar) Avatar
    Tangled Up In Music (by Ovidiu Boar)

    Nice article, just one thing I have to add: Carl, Dennis and especially Brian Wilson all played on Pet Sounds. And even with so many session musicians coming and going, Brian was still absolutely in charge of the whole thing, often telling those musicians what and how to play, often coming up with parts for their respective instruments. It was all coming from his head.


  2. J. Avatar

    As Ovidiu says, although Brian had arranged things while the band was on tour, both Carl and Dennis played on the album (Brian too, of course).

    Anyhoo, moving on from that! The real bargain here is At Folsom Prison! £2.50! That’s a steal!

    I look forward to seeing the complete collection …


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      My source is Steven Gaines’ Heroes and Villains, which says that they didn’t. It goes on, “when the other members of the group returned to LA they found that most of the tracks were complete. Brian was ready for them to plug in their vocals -and they didn’t like it…he would sometimes let the group do the vocals the way they wanted, then, after they left the studio he would wipe the vocals off completely and finish the track himself…”
      Steven Gaines book was published in 1986, so perhaps new evidence has come to light that contradicts what he says?


      1. J. Avatar

        Yeah, I’m fairly certain the Wrecking Crew and others done most of the recording, but those 3 played on at least one track. I may be wrong … ?


      2. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

        You could well be right. Further research is the answer! Will have to find another Beach Boys book…. Anyone know of one?


      3. J. Avatar

        I’ve read a few bits and pieces in magazines and online, but have I Just Wasn’t Made For These Times by Charles Granata. Haven’t read it in a while, but it was a great read and really focusses on Pet Sounds. I’ll have a gander and see if there’s anything specific mentioned about the playing …

        Certainly a book worth investigating.


    2. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      And you’re right, I was very happy with my “Folsom Prison” find! A great bargain!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. J. Avatar

        At Folsom is, quite possibly, my favourite of the prison records. Really great find …


  3. 45spin Avatar

    Fantastic finds and interesting enough all firmly planted in the sixties, your point about George Martin reflection about Strawberry Fields & Penny Lane is totally new to me and makes me wonder how different the album would of turned out. Great post


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      Yes – what tracks would they have not written or dropped? And would it have flowed so well?


  4. […] …and my £44.49 had so far bought this: What would be next? Find out in part seven via this link.. […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: