The Neil Young Deluxe Vinyl Box Set Project Part 5: More Records


The Project: Is it possible to make a “Deluxe” Vinyl Box Set of Neil Young albums from the original vinyl rather than spending lots of money on re-issues? I am trying to find out… 

The Story So Far: I have Zuma and Time Fades Away, but need two more albums to replicate the official “Series 5-8” Box Set. Once everything is found, the box set is going on eBay – at cost – for one lucky person to (hopefully) enjoy… But Time is Fading Away fast (see what I did there…). 

Confused? Click these links for Part one, part two, part three and part four

In the same way that the slightly-wounded-antelope-filled plains of the Serengeti appeal greatly to hungry lions, so does the Spitalfields Record Fair in London appeal to the grizzle-faced record collecting fraternity. There’s the thrill of the chase, plenty of choice and a chance to separate the weak/cheap from the rest of the herd, if that’s not stretching the analogy a bit too far. 

Mind you, it wasn’t exactly bursting with Ditch Trilogy Neil Young albums on the day I went looking for them…

With Zuma and Time Fades Away secured, I was half way there, with just two albums to complete the DIY Box Set, namely:

  • On The Beach
  • Tonight’s The Night

Having searched at one “most likely” stall for twenty minutes with no luck at all I was starting to feel a little grumpy. At the last fair, that stall had two copies of “On The Beach” buried away somewhere, but both appeared taken. Then, just as I was losing hope I finally found some Neil Young albums: 

A copy of Re-ac-tor for £5. Not helpful. 

Then “Comes A Time”. Two copies. Both £5.

Then “Stars and Bars” and even “Trans”, then copies of “Harvest” and “After The Gold Rush”. 

It was like the records were taunting me. 

“Here’s every Neil Young album you aren’t looking for…” they were saying. I was half expecting copies of the still unreleased “Chrome Dreams” and “Homegrown” to pop up. I got the uncomfortable feeling if I turned my back the records would start laughing at me, so I bought “Stars…” and “Comes a Time” just to spite them (and because £5 was a good price). 

I moved on, slightly shaken. 

At another stall I found both albums, but “On The Beach” was £45 and “Tonight’s The Night” was £25. At that price it would have made more sense to buy the reissues. However, I had picked up my own copy of the latter for £15, so felt £25 was too steep. What’s more, the copy of “On The Beach” wasn’t even a first pressing. 

You can easily tell an early pressing of “On The Beach” because it has a nice floral pattern on the inside of the LP, similar to the kind of material that garden furniture was made of in the seventies and eighties and, if you live in the sleepier parts of the Home Counties, the nineties. 


The sleeve of On The Beach. Note the patterned interior.
A vendor charging £45 for a later, plain-sleeved copy was rather chancing his arm I felt. It’s a bit like a car salesman trying to pass off a rusty, brown C-reg mini as brand new, or having someone tell you the current Drifters line up is the original one. 

It was time to negotiate. 

Record fairs are friendly places. The sort of all too rare gatherings of like minded souls where a beginner may attempt to barter without risking a punch in the mouth, especially given the variables around the price and condition of every item. However, you have to know your limits. I didn’t bother with “On The Beach”. If a vendor thinks a record is worth more than twice its *actual* value, he probably also believes in unicorns, goblins, that rich people pay tax and  Gary Barlow has talent, so it’s best to leave him to his delusions. On the other hand, this particular vendor had a very nice copy of “Tonight’s The Night” which a sensible offer might just make affordable. 

It had the “Waterface” inscription on the run out groove of the LP but no insert. The original insert had a fake suicide note written by “Waterface”. All very strange. It was a UK pressing with a yellow label, not black as per the US pressings. 

After a brief and friendly exchange I secured the LP for an acceptable £17. 

I looked everywhere else, but there was no sign of another copy of “On The Beach”. 

I drifted to a final stall, and slightly in desperation I asked a vendor if he had a copy of “On The Beach”?

“Oh, yeah mate – I’m pretty sure I’ve got one – it’s in that £5 crate over there”

My heart leapt. Not only did he have the album, but it was at a bargain price! I didn’t hold out much hope it would be a first pressing, but you never know!

There have been disappointments in history. Take the Trojans. They thought the Greeks had left their children some lovely toys, only to wake up in the morning to find their impregnable city burned to the ground. 


Now I’ve had a few bitter, crushing disappointments in my life, including listening to The Killers’ second album, but few were as bitter and crushing as how I felt when I found this…..

This was surely the Road To Hell for any box set. I thought about it for a moment, but concluded it wouldn’t do to slip that in and hope for the best. My 100% eBay feedback would be on shaky ground…

Then I found another stall I had previously overlooked and this one had an entire Neil Young section. I said a silent prayer and dived in. Not literally, obviously. That would have been most unseemly. 

Oh joy! This seller had what must have been the only other copies of On The Beach in the market that day. And he had two copies. Both early pressings with the garden-furniture-print inside, with original inner sleeves, one UK and one US, both on sale for £20 each. It was a fair price. I took a while, compared the two – there was little between them condition-wise, and plumped for the US version on the grounds that as a US artist the US pressing would likely sound marginally better. 


the US pressing of Neil Young’s On The Beach
A quick round of negotiation secured the LP for £18: that was £35 spent on the day against an asking price of £45. A good morning’s work, and the box set was complete!


The complete Neil Young Box Set – with all the original albums
Total cost of the box set was as follows:

  • Time Fades Away: £13
  • On The Beach: £18
  • Tonight’s The Night: £17
  • Zuma: £10
  • Box: £1 from a charity shop
  • Decorating the box so it doesn’t say “Orchestral Magic” on the front: £4.70
  • Replica ticket stubs: £0
  • Exclusive Liner Notes by Every Record Tells A Story: £0
  • Neil-o-vision special effect: £0
  • Replica “Pono” player (actually a Toblerone): £1.00
  • Total: £64.70

Compared to the £106.35 that the re-release is currently being offered for on Amazon, that’s a bargain. 

How much better is it to get really good sounding original copies of the albums, all pressed from the original stampers, all guaranteed analogue (because digital didn’t exist then) and all over forty years old, (thus being sixty years closer to being *actual antiques*) rather than buying mere replicas for nearly twice the price? 

So now comes the hard work…

I already own copies of these albums. I’m slightly jealous of the copy of Zuma in the box set, because the previous owner of my own copy used that inner as a colouring book. But overall I have no need of the box set, so I’m now going to put the Neil Young Deluxe Vinyl Box Set: DIY Edition for sale on eBay. 

If no-one buys it, I’m going to look a complete idiot. 

Even more than usual, that is to say…

But surely there’s someone out there who’d rather have the original albums than replicas? Or someone who couldn’t afford the official box set but for whom now the price is affordable? 

It’s on eBay for £64.70 plus postage right now. It’ll be up for a week or so. 

That’s a bargain for original copies of those four albums, all of which I have played and can confirm sound great…

You even get the exclusive liner notes, and – some might say crucially – some chocolate. 

Here’s the link. I hope there’s someone out there who will love having the collection of albums wrapped in all that lovely tissue paper. 

Happy bidding…





12 responses to “The Neil Young Deluxe Vinyl Box Set Project Part 5: More Records”

  1. mikeladano Avatar

    Brilliant series. I love this. It’s been quite a fun adventure and I think your NY box is a steal at that price.

    Lol…Gary Barlow!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. rossmurray1 Avatar

    Who doesn’t love a good quest. Hope it reaps rewards.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. David Avatar

    Highly amusing. Whilst I didn’t really doubt it you have just had me checking all of my Neil vinyl as to condition, inserts etc and I am pleased to say my copy of On The Beach does have the “garden furniture” sleeve but as I bought it at the time of release probably in One Stop Records Tottenham Court Road that isn’t a surprise. I hope some “young” person out there takes up your offer.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. J. Avatar

    Great stuff. Really enjoyed this ‘mission’ … hopefully the set finds a home!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. ianbalentine Avatar

    A really enjoyable series, and the box is beautiful because it actually comes with a story! Well done.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      Thanks Ian – glad you enjoyed the articles.


  6. punchyknucklehead Avatar

    Love this, I see you were successful. It’s the sort of madcap idea I would do.


  7. Johnny Yuma Avatar
    Johnny Yuma

    Great idea and an even greater story, Thank you very much!


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      Thank you! Glad you enjoyed it.


  8. Gerard O’Carroll Avatar
    Gerard O’Carroll

    Come to this late, so glad I didn’t chuck out my vinyl in the ‘90’s, I am 57 and started buying records in the mid 70’s, didn’t get into Neil Young until about 1980, in those days you could walk into a record shop and buy original issue albums (even into the mid ‘80’s), they must have been hanging around in ware houses, all my Neil Young albums are original albums (am in Australia) including ‘On The Beach ‘, with printed inside cover, have looked after them so they play great,

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      Doesn’t matter that you are late! Thank you for dropping by and glad you still have all your original LPs 👍


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: