Crown and Treaty Mercury Prize

And The 2012 Album Of The Year Is….Sweet Billy Pilgrim’s Crown and Treaty

Crown and Treaty Mercury Prize
Tim Elsenburg of Sweet Billy Pilgrim

It may only be July, but I think Sweet Billy Pilgrim’s Crown and Treaty is the best album of 2012…

When a friend bought me Crown and Treaty I knew nothing about Sweet Billy Pilgrim. From the name, I pictured an American singer, perhaps from the Deep South. With no expectations I hit the Play button. When it finished I stared, astonished, at the CD player, as though expecting it to talk to me. It said little. I played the last track Blue Sky Falls again just to make sure I hadn’t imagined how good it was. The tune builds and builds, before a guitar riff distantly related to The BeatlesDig a Pony bulldozes through the chorus and envelops you in a joyful wall of sound that might bring a tear to the eye if you aren’t very, very careful.

I played the CD three times straight.

“Mercury Prize winner 2012” has a certain ring to it….

It is rare to judge a record purely by how it sounds. I had no information, no X-Factor style back story of overcoming a stutter or having a slightly poorly mother-in-law to gain my sympathy.

Tragic back stories are not confined solely to reality TV. Bon Iver rocketed to fame after locking himself in a log cabin for six months whilst he sulked over a break up*. Wilco’s Jeff Tweedy was addicted to painkillers. Razorlight’s Johnny Borrell once bought a corked bottle of Burgundy in Waitrose and it was too late to take it back. Out of such tragedies can come great art.

However, Sweet Billy Pilgrim had no need for such artifice. It turns out Sweet Billy Pilgrim is not an exotic figure hewn from Mississippi mud, but a four piece band from Wingrave, Buckinghamshire consisting of Tim Elsenburg (guitar / vocals), Anthony Bishop (bass /banjo), Alistair Hamer (drums) and Jana Carpenter (guitar / vocals). In 2009 their second album Twice Born Men was nominated for a Mercury Prize.  Elsenburg was a tradesman, having just installed a toilet when he got the call to say he was nominated. The album itself was recorded in a shed. (There is no record of where they kept the lawnmower and the band is strangely silent on the subject).  Although they lost out to eventual winner Speech Debelle, the band regrouped, made a key hire in Jana Carpenter and (after appearing on an episode of The IT Crowd) began work on the follow up. Crown and Treaty is the result and as I have intimated, it is a beautiful and amazing record.

What does it sound like? Well – you could just press the Play button on the Spotify button below. But if that is too tricky, then cast your mind back to the scene in the sixties Batman film (bear with me here) where the United World Organization’s Security Council is kidnapped, turned to dust and improperly rehydrated, resulting in their taking on each others’ characteristics. Imagine if at the table instead of the UWO Security Council there had been various members of Elbow, Radiohead, Fleet Foxes and perhaps Robert Plant and Alison Krauss. Sweet Billy Pilgrim would have been the result. That’s what they sound like.

“Robin, can we take out the bit from Thom Yorke that makes him want to just play electronica?”

Perhaps you’d better use that Spotify button. We’ll move on: to Bush Hall, where Sweet Billy Pilgrim played a live show last night.

Embellished with Dan Garland on keys and Barney Muller on lead guitar, Sweet Billy Pilgrim mix Radiohead’s rhythms, Fleet-Fox harmonies and soaring choruses that Elbow would kill for. Elsenburg’s voice blends with Carpenter’s like a well-iced Hendrick’s and Tonic.

Crown and Treaty

Standing on a stage slightly larger than a postage stamp, the band showed why the Mercury judges had showered them with plaudits.

SWP focused mainly on material from the last two albums, but added in an impromptu version of I Wanna Dance With Somebody (“we rehearsed this before she died, in case anyone thinks it’s in bad taste” explained Elsenburg. “It’s still in bad taste” joked Bishop).

Crown and Treaty Bush Hall Mercury Prize

After filming the audience to update their Facebook profile picture, the band overcame any doubts that they would be able to reproduce such an intricately beautiful album live. The performance was immaculate. Songs from Crown and Treaty sandwiched older tunes, and the main part of the show ended with the crowd singing along to Blue Sky Falls. Two encores and they were gone into the night…

After the show, Jana and Tim told me how they had connected through Twitter: “After meeting up we played Two of Us by the Beatles and a Robert Plant and Allison Krauss song” Jana explained.

Tim went on, “The audience went quiet when we played. But in the right way”.

Whilst recording the Crown and Treaty album Sweet Billy Pilgrim took the unorthodox step of performing at fans’ homes. “It was a way to keep playing and try out arrangements” explained Tim. The band will be very welcome to play at Every Record’s home. I suspect however that they will soon have better offers.

I have a tenner on them to win this year’s Mercury Prize. Buy the album. Even if you live in the USA. See them live. If Fleet Foxes can sell out Hammersmith, then this lot should eventually fill the O2. It’s rare to hear a record by a band that stops you in your tracks. Crown and Treaty is one of those records. Sweet Billy Pilgrim is one of those bands.

Record #68 : Sweet Billy Pilgrim – Blue Sky Falls

* This is a harsh view of Bon Iver’s situation….


12 responses to “And The 2012 Album Of The Year Is….Sweet Billy Pilgrim’s Crown and Treaty”

  1. Col Avatar

    This is new to me – but will give it a go!


    1. every record tells a story Avatar

      Great – let me know if you agree…


  2. anjakimberley Avatar

    I could barely open my eyes thismorning when I read this review (WordPress addiction) but the light of ‘must listen’ managed to get into my peepholes… A little more with it I got quite lost in the album on my way to work. A skip through the tracks by my colleague didn’t yeild such a return but I am now going to try my housemate, I know he’ll love it as much as me an probably more…


    1. every record tells a story Avatar

      I love the fact that this album attracts new listeners. When you hear it you want everyone else to hear it too. Thanks for giving it a spin!
      I didn’t mention the drummer either. He’s very, very good…


  3. wordsformusic Avatar

    I listened to it to, and I really liked it. I’m shocked that I haven’t heard it before “/, this will definitely be brought and have a healthy life in my car for a month or so.

    Really like your blog, you always seem to pull something out which I haven’t listened and I really enjoy, so please keep going and treating me to music.


    1. every record tells a story Avatar

      Thanks – and I’m really pleased you like the record.


  4. Jason Wendleton Avatar

    Best album of 2012, in July? That’s a bold statement. I want to check this album out, but it’s not available here in the States through Spotify. I guess I’ll have to do something I haven’t done in a long, long, time: buy it 100% blind. I’ll let you know what I think.


    1. every record tells a story Avatar

      The pressure! Love the fact you’ll do things the old Skool way and buy blind. Thanks for having faith!


  5. purplemary54 Avatar

    Ooh, thanks for the rec. I’ll look them up.


  6. […] news reaches my ears from Every Record Tells A Story favourites (and ERTAS Album of the Year 2012 winners) Sweet Billy […]


  7. […] I championed new music. The likes of Sweet Billy Pilgrim, Drenge, Royal Blood, London Grammar, John Grant, Parquet Courts, Courtney Barnett and (most […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: