Roy Carr

The Beatles Stereo Box Set Challenge – The Conclusion

Box Set

Buying The Beatles on Vinyl

Spoiler alert: This is Part 6 of a six-part series. If you want to start at the beginning – click this link.

The story so far: A bet has been struck between me and my friend Chris: Can I buy a complete set of Beatles records on vinyl for less money than the 2012 Re-issued Box Set? Deadline day is the 20th October. The clock is ticking and the stakes are high…the loser has to listen to a Mariah Carey album. Ten times. Trips to record fairs have found all but one of the records – for £200 – well under budget. But Past Masters is missing and impossible to get hold of. Out of options, I call Chris the day before the deadline to concede defeat.

So the day came when Chris was to come over to present me formally with a Mariah Carey CD. He was grinning like a Cheshire cat that had just eaten an entire can of Elmlea in one go…

“Bad luck!” he sympathised (insincerely) “So near and yet…” he let the words trail off…

“Mariah Carey eh? I never thought I’d see the day! Do wait until I have left before you put the thing on won’t you? And I want a screen shot of those play counts on your iTunes playlist: no cheating!”

I let him carry on a bit. With an unnecessary flourish he began to present me with a CD shaped packaged that he had wrapped in paper and had tied a little bow of ribbon around. But I had an ace up my sleeve.

“Just before I take the CD from you Chris, let me tell you about a funny thing that happened to me today” I began. I wore a poker face.

Chris looked at me. He hesitated.

“I took a call from Bob – from Leigh Records – just a couple of hours ago. He told me that a bloke came in with fifteen copies of Sgt Pepper yesterday. Isn’t it amazing what people come in with…?”

Chris looked wary all of a sudden. He waited for me to finish. He suspected something was up.

“He also had something else. Would you believe it?! He had a copy of Past Masters Vol 1&2…..”

I let the words hang in the air for a while.

“….which Bob let me have for thirty five quid.”

My triumph was palpable. I allowed myself a smirk. I may have raised an mirthful eyebrow.

“And guess what else he had? A very rare double vinyl LP…of something called The Emancipation of Mimi by Ms Mariah Carey. Which he let me have for nothing!” This was true. Bob had been sufficiently tickled by the idea of the bet – and forfeit – to gift me this LP, which had been in stock for “quite a few years” without having been sold. He doubted it ever would be of interest to anyone…

Chris looked stunned. But he’s made of stern stuff. He wasn’t finished yet.

“Did he have the book?” he asked quietly.

The book! I had forgotten about the book! I thought quickly.

“Er, I have the book. Wait here.”

I ran upstairs and pulled out my copy of The Beatles: An Illustrated Record by Roy Carr and Tony Tyler. It’s a great glossy history of The Beatles that covers each of their records in turn – and is LP sized. Surely a reasonable replacement…?

Roy Carr

To cut a long story short, after a stewards enquiry, (and an assessment of the book ‘s value on eBay / Amazon) the book was allowed.

I had won the bet! Mariah Carey could wait another day. And another. And another.

So what did I learn from this adventure? Not only did I manage to buy an entire set of 14 Beatles Albums on vinyl for just (just?) £235, but a good proportion were early (i.e. sixties) or first pressings, that should hold their value. Will the new box set records be as good an investment? I don’t know. The seventies re-pressings clearly haven’t held their value like the sixties originals – but they are pressed on noticeably thinner vinyl: this will be the first time the complete set will be available on heavy 180g vinyl – so maybe that might help. I am sure audiophiles will enjoy the chance to play these records crackle-free on heavy vinyl, although I rather take the view that many songs were most often first heard on AM radios – and the magic of a record like Please Please Me is enhanced little by playing it on an expensive turntable. Not that I have one. I can’t afford it having shelled out all that money on the records.

Walking around the record fairs and bric-a-brac shops also got me lovely copies of Imagine, Aladdin Sane, Sound Affects, Bowie’s Stage and Low, the Red and Blue Best-of Albums…

The Blue Album

…plus classic books such as Diary of a Rock n Roll Star, Shaky and Our Band Could Be Your Life – all for just over twenty quid. The Bowie record alone is apparently worth far more.

Of the new pressings in the Box-Set, The White Album looks like it will be the biggest bargain – I struggled to find a first pressing for less than £60 with the poster and photos, so the re-release (as an individual record) ought to be a good way to buy this LP for less money. I think Abbey Road and Sgt Pepper might also benefit from a 180g version.

And Chris? We shared a good bottle of wine to drown his sorrows. He’s probably listening to Mariah right now. I think he secretly likes it…

Record #115: The Beatles – I Feel Fine (PS watch this funny but badly-synced YouTube clip to see Ringo on a bicycle instead of his drum kit…)





25 responses to “The Beatles Stereo Box Set Challenge – The Conclusion”

  1. Push Avatar

    Phew!! That was a great series of posts – but I can’t help thinking that you were very lucky at the end there. The Beatles Illustrated Record is a fabulous book, though. I know Roy Carr quite well and mentioned him on my blog earlier this year, in a piece about the old NME tapes (C81, C86, etc), most of which were compiled by Roy.


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      It was very touch and go! Funny how things turn out. And I know where you can buy fifteen Sgt Peppers if you ever want them…
      I have a copy of the C86 tape somewhere and remember your blogging about it. It’s cool that you know Roy – very ex-Melody Maker of you! You can tell him I like his book next time you see him – and my NME Book of Rock 2 to which he contributed…


  2. Jaap Avatar

    Great story.
    Made me remember how fond Patrick Bateman in American Psycho is of Whitney Houston, see


    1. Jaap Avatar

      Damn, I think I got ms. Houston and ms. Carey mixed up. Nevermind this.


      1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

        An understandable error!


  3. mikeladano Avatar

    Much relief! Good for you!


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      Phew! (wipes brow, looks relieved…)


  4. Avatar

    Great posts! Congratulations!


  5. Heavy Metal Overload Avatar

    Well done, Bob at Leigh Records! It would have been a shame to have gone to all that effort and expense just to end up with Mariah’s ear damage. Just saw a display of the new Beatles vinyl in my local Fopp. They do look lovely.


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      He’s a top guy! Haven’t seen the new records yet – but then I don’t need to…


  6. Heavy Metal Overload Avatar

    I think you should get Chris to do a guest review of Mariah. It’s only fair.


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      Great suggestion! I’ll ask him!


  7. Dado Avatar

    Brilliant stuff. Loved it.


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      Thanks for the Twitter support!


  8. […] The Beatles Stereo Box Set Challenge Part 4 The Beatles Stereo Box Set Challenge – The Conclusion […]


  9. ianbalentine Avatar

    Fantastic series, I really and truly enjoyed it! I’m even happier that you didn’t have to listen to MC, as I hear those who do end up sicking an ice pick in their ear after a few minutes. I hope you do more of these, the stuff on grading and collecting was fascinating.


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      Thank you! Not as happy as I am I can assure you – although it would have made a good subject to write about…


  10. MikeK Avatar

    That was a good read….certainly needed it after reading the reviews of how bad the pressings of the new box set are here in the U.S. Funny thing is that I had remarked in a forum that if my box set that is on the way has bad LP’s in it…I am going to wish I had just finished out the rest of my UK collection on Ebay for less money!


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      I hadn’t heard any grumbling about the new records – it’s a shame if they’re not up to scratch – albeit will only reinforce the value of the originals…


  11. thomoz Avatar

    You can get all the 13 core releases (no MMT) in a BC-13 “Blue Box” (mine is from Holland and set me back only $210). The material on Past Masters is spread over three vintage UK comps – ‘Beatles Rarities’ (blue cover, it’s all the b-sides – and comes in the blue BC-13), ‘Hey Jude’ and ‘Oldies But Goodies’.- so those would have been an alternative. BTW, the best Beatles book is by BOB SPITZ.


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      That’s interesting – an eighties box set! I wish I had known! Having had a quick look on eBay, the most recent one sold cost £240, which is a similar amount to what I paid – albeit I got some sixties originals. As ever, it is a balance between condition and having an original pressing.
      Thanks for dropping by – much appreciated. I will have to check out that book you mentioned too.


  12. Jason Wendleton Avatar

    I’m so glad you were able to win! I was pulling for ya. I have a record player, but I think I’m going to skip on the vinyl reissues. Mostly because I have this music already (some on vinyl) and I have too much shit.

    That said, the fact that they’re reissuing the albums on vinyl is a testament to to the remarkable resilience of vinyl as a format. I mean, they’re not reissuing the albums on cassette, now are they?

    This was a great series. You need to go more of these challenges.


    1. Every Record Tells A Story Avatar

      Thanks – let me know if you want to set me any…


  13. Vinyl Connection Avatar

    Very fine indeed. Nicely done on all counts (the acquisitions and the writing).


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: